“Has my expenses claim been paid?” If the honest answer means opening the bank statement, then payroll, then a spreadsheet, your process has a gap at the end. Most expense tools are good at getting a claim approved. Fewer help you track expense reimbursements once the claim leaves the approver, which is where double payments, short payments and awkward conversations happen.

The fix is simple to describe: every claim moves through the same few states, and the last one records what was actually paid.

Why track expense reimbursements at all?

Because “approved” and “paid” are different facts, and finance needs both.

  • Claimants want to know when the money arrives, without having to ask.
  • Finance needs to know what’s still owed at month end, and must not pay the same claim twice.
  • Your accountant wants to see the approval and the payment for each claim, together, with the receipt.

There’s a compliance angle too. HMRC’s guidance for employers says that to pay expenses free of tax under the exemption, you must have a system in place to check them, and that “your employees cannot check their own expenses” (HMRC, expenses and benefits for employers: exemptions and dispensations, checked 27 October 2026). An approval followed by a recorded payment is the kind of trail that shows a checking system working. Whether your arrangements meet HMRC’s conditions is for your accountant to confirm.

The states a claim should pass through

A claim that finance can track has a clear life:

  1. Draft: the claimant is still adding lines.
  2. Submitted: waiting for the approver.
  3. Approved (or sent back with a question, or declined with a reason).
  4. Exported: in the accounts, with the export recorded.
  5. Paid: with the date and the amount.

The point of the list is that a claim is always in exactly one state, and everyone can see which. “I think Sam’s was in last month’s run” stops being an answer.

How to track expense reimbursements against what was claimed

The key step is recording the amount paid, not just ticking “paid”.

Most of the time the two match. When they don’t, you want to see it. A short payment happens for ordinary reasons: a line was over policy and paid at the allowed amount, a duplicate was removed, a foreign card charge came in different from the receipt. If you only record “paid”, the difference disappears. If you record the amount, the claim shows that it’s short, and by how much, and someone can explain why.

Two habits help:

  • Only personal money is owed. If a line was paid on a company card, or invoiced straight to the company, it belongs on the claim for the record, but nothing is owed to the claimant for it. Record the payment method on each line so the amount owed is right before anyone pays it.
  • Pay from the export, not from memory. If payroll or the bank run uses the same approved, exported claims, the amount paid and the amount owed start from the same number.

Stop a claim being paid twice

Double payment usually comes from one of two places: the same claim exported in two months, or the same receipt on two claims.

  • Lock what’s paid. Once a claim is marked paid, it shouldn’t be possible to export it again by mistake. An export you can re-run (because the file went missing, say) is fine; a paid claim slipping into next month’s file is not.
  • Fix submitted claims properly. A submitted claim should stay as it was submitted. If something is wrong, send it back so the claimant corrects it and the approver sees the change, rather than editing the numbers quietly. Small coding changes, such as a nominal code, are a different matter and can be allowed before export, as long as the change is recorded with who and when.
  • Flag possible duplicates. The same merchant, day and amount on two lines is worth a second look. Most are innocent (two coffees, same café); the warning just makes sure someone looks.

Keep the whole trail together

When the claim is paid, the receipt, the approval, the export and the payment should all sit in one place. HMRC’s VAT notice says that, generally, you must keep business records for VAT purposes for at least six years (HMRC, VAT Notice 700/21, section 2.4, last updated 18 March 2024, checked 27 October 2026). PAYE records, including taxable expenses and benefits, are kept for three years from the end of the tax year they relate to (HMRC, PAYE for employers: keeping records, checked 27 October 2026). Six years covers both. Ask your accountant if your business needs longer.

Where this fits in month end

Tracking reimbursements is the last step of the month-end routine: cut-off, reminder, approval, export, then paid. We’ve written up the earlier steps in month-end expenses without the chase, and the tax rules behind each line are in the finance guide to expense claims and VAT.

How Sign2Approve Expenses closes the loop

Finance has its own view of claims: approved, then exported, then paid. Each line records how it was paid (personal card, personal cash, company card or invoiced to the company), and only personal money is counted as owed to the claimant.

When you’ve paid, through payroll or the bank, you mark the claim paid with the date and the amount. If the amount is less than was claimed, the short payment shows on the claim. An export can be produced again, but a claim once paid can’t be exported again by mistake. A submitted claim is fixed: finance can change a line’s nominal code or allocation until that line is exported, recorded with who and when, and anything else goes back to the claimant. Possible duplicates (same merchant, day and amount) are flagged to the claimant, the approver and finance.

We don’t make payments, issue cards or hold money. You pay people the way you do now; Sign2Approve records it against the claim.

Sign2Approve Expenses tracks every claim from approved to paid, free for up to 3 claimants with no card: see Expenses.